Quite a bit of pain for the gain of electric services to Newbury.
Yes, all pain and no gain for people wanting to travel to/from stations west of Newbury, i.e. Kintbuty, Bedywn Hungerford and Pewsey.
Once the much-loved
HSTs▸ are replaced by the new Hitachi trains, there is likely to be even more pain due to the hard "ironing board" seats that they have.
Won't stations west of Newbury as far as Bedwyn benefit from an hourly service with IET▸ 's replacing (mostly) Turbos, with better connections to the west - that's surely an improvement, even if you do think the seats are too hard (which I personally don't)?
And won't Pewsey benefit from a far more clockface pattern of services than the random service it currently receives? For me, the Berks & Hants line is one of the ones that benefits the most from electrification and new trains, although it does seem like this year is going to be very disruptive.
From what I have seen, there is some woolliness in public information and plans have changed a bit along the way.
* From Reading to Newbury there will be two stopping trains an hour one calling at all stations and one only at major stations. The all stations train will be electric, and run just between Reading and Newbury. The major-stations-only train will be an IET from London, calling at Reading, major stations to Newbury, Kintbury, Hungerford and Bedwyn where it will terminate.
* Every 2 hours, a "semifast" IET is planned from London to Reading, Pewsey, Westbury, Castle Cary and Taunton; then on to Exeter St David's is suggested but probably not beyond. Any stops between Reading and Pewsey are unclear to me.
* Every hour, an express will run - Paddington, Reading, Taunton, Tiverton, Exeter, Newton Abbott, Plymouth. Additional stops west of Exeter and continuation on into Cornwall - I'll let others comment.
So ...
Kintbury, Hungerford and Bedwyn
gain the replacement of a turbo with a five car IET.
Pewsey and Westbury both
gain trains that fill the current massive gaps during the day
Pewsey, Westbury and Castle Cary
loose though trains beyond Exeter
Taunton, Exeter, Plymouth, Cornwall
gain improvements to their London and Reading services
Kintbury, Hungrford and Bedwyn
probably see
no change in the virtually zero provision from them via Pewsey
Frome will see
no change (?) - virtually no service to its county town of Taunton, and perhaps one peak train to London
All trains used on these services will be
new.