Great Western Coffee Shop

All across the Great Western territory => Across the West => Topic started by: Mark A on September 18, 2023, 09:41:54



Title: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: Mark A on September 18, 2023, 09:41:54
Didn't have my glasses on, and was struck this morning by the coffee shop's disruptions map's ominous orange glow, briefly matching the sky outside earlier. I then wondered: Does 'Reformed' imply trains that have a different number of carriages from what was intended?

Mark


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: grahame on September 18, 2023, 09:47:19
Didn't have my glasses on, and was struck this morning by the coffee shop's disruptions map's ominous orange glow, briefly matching the sky outside earlier. I then wondered: Does 'Reformed' imply trains that have a different number of carriages from what was intended?

Mark

Yes - and in the case of the TransWilts service we have 3 carriages not 2 today so it's a positive change.  I am thinking that some adjustment of map colours might be helpful as cancelled, short run and reformed look too similar.  Delayed - blue, Loo problems - brown and Additions - green are probably OK.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: IndustryInsider on September 18, 2023, 11:24:33
Would it be helpful to have two maps?  One covering the more serious issues of cancellations and short runs, and one covering loos and additions?  Mind you, where would the 'reformed' category fit in as generally speaking a one carriage reduction isn't the end of the world and a long form is usually good news.  However a 5 vice 10 IET or a 2 vice 5 on a Cardiff<>Porstmouth can be a different matter.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: grahame on September 18, 2023, 11:33:22
Would it be helpful to have two maps?  One covering the more serious issues of cancellations and short runs, and one covering loos and additions?  Mind you, where would the 'reformed' category fit in as generally speaking a one carriage reduction isn't the end of the world and a long form is usually good news.  However a 5 vice 10 IET or a 2 vice 5 on a Cardiff<>Porstmouth can be a different matter.

If you click on the map, you get a new display with a larger map that you can tailor in this way - see http://new.passenger.chat/better/map.html?ecs=838.9249877929688&wye=524&basemap=AABBABADAA&001=A&002=A&003=D&004=B&005=A&006=B&007=A&008=D&doit=update%21 as an example but bear in mind that's dynamic so viewing the page later I don't know what you'll see.

There may be scope for individuals to tune like with the colour scheme and the expansion of abbreviations.  I would be reluctant to give up more screen space to a second map, or have two different maps alternating or to leave off shortform - but listening.



Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: grahame on September 18, 2023, 12:36:24
At the risk of mucking about with a well loved system ... I have re-coloured "reformed".  Please tell me if you love it or hate it. It can easily be undone.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: grahame on September 19, 2023, 09:07:28
At the risk of mucking about with a well loved system ... I have re-coloured "reformed".  Please tell me if you love it or hate it. It can easily be undone.

Zero feedback on the colour change.  Personally I find the pink an improvement over the orange as it differentiates far better and unless I get comment back to the contrary, I propose to leave it pink.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: PrestburyRoad on September 19, 2023, 09:13:45
Quote
Quote from: grahame on Yesterday at 12:36:24 pm
At the risk of mucking about with a well loved system ... I have re-coloured "reformed".  Please tell me if you love it or hate it. It can easily be undone.

Zero feedback on the colour change.  Personally I find the pink an improvement over the orange as it differentiates far better and unless I get comment back to the contrary, I propose to leave it pink.

I like the change - thank you for making it.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: Mark A on September 19, 2023, 09:37:12
Ah, I was hanging back on commenting to let the colour settle and also to see how it sat with a more typical day of disruption. It sits well, but what do you think of giving the pink a little more bite, as the colour itself recedes a bit into the white background? As for the map itself, I just love it, and it must have been very pleasing to set it up and then see it doing its thing of its own accord.

Mark


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: broadgage on September 20, 2023, 01:15:36
At the risk of mucking about with a well loved system ... I have re-coloured "reformed".  Please tell me if you love it or hate it. It can easily be undone.

Zero feedback on the colour change.  Personally I find the pink an improvement over the orange as it differentiates far better and unless I get comment back to the contrary, I propose to leave it pink.

I presumed that pink was temporary and related to gay rights or something similar, but no harm in making it permanent.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: grahame on September 20, 2023, 07:15:39
From research ... (https://www.invisionapp.com/inside-design/quick-guide-color-palette/) - there's quite a science in choosing colours.

Quote
Quote
What colors mean

Red: energy, power, passion
Orange: joy, enthusiasm, creativity
Yellow: happiness, intellect, energy
Green: ambition, growth, freshness, safety
Blue: tranquility, confidence, intelligence
Purple: luxury, ambition, creativity
Black: power, elegance, mystery
White: cleanliness, purity, perfection

A note about accessibility

One challenge that UX designers have to keep in mind is meeting the needs of site visitors with color blindness or color vision deficiency (CVD). This condition affects more than eight percent of men and about 0.5 percent of women of Northern European ancestry. It’s up to UX designers to employ color blind-friendly palettes adapted and configured to accommodate the multiple varieties of colorblindness. Check out this post from the Pinterest Engineering team on the ways they approach CVD accessibility on their predominantly visual platform.

Our map is showing - for the most part - negative features whereas the colour listing above highlights positive aspects, so it's no more than food for thought.


Title: Re: Orange glow in the sky. No, hang on, it's on the coffeeshop disruption map
Post by: Witham Bobby on September 20, 2023, 09:34:21
From research ... (https://www.invisionapp.com/inside-design/quick-guide-color-palette/) - there's quite a science in choosing colours.

Quote
Quote
What colors mean
Yellow: happiness, intellect, energy
Blue: tranquility, confidence, intelligence

Our map is showing - for the most part - negative features whereas the colour listing above highlights positive aspects, so it's no more than food for thought.

Ryanair, Aldi and Lidl all use blue and yellow, quite heavily.  Just sayin'



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net