Great Western Coffee Shop

Journey by Journey => Bristol (WECA) Commuters => Topic started by: Lee on March 12, 2008, 09:29:16



Title: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Lee on March 12, 2008, 09:29:16
That could have been a tight squeeze, I would imagine :

07:33 Weston-Super-Mare to Cardiff Central due 09:24
This train has been revised.

Service formed of 1 Carriage.


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: mada on March 12, 2008, 18:38:47
Same 153 worked Cardiff to BTM at peak earlier. I had to wait for them to strap a 150 to it at BTM.   >:(


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: John R on March 12, 2008, 20:07:18
The 0840 from Weston was also a 153 today (and earlier this week). Even at that time will be cosy by the time it arrives at TM.


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Timmer on March 12, 2008, 20:15:48
Would I be right in saying that a 153 was covering a diagram in place of a poorly 143 today?


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Lee on March 12, 2008, 20:59:10
The 0840 from Weston was also a 153 today (and earlier this week). Even at that time will be cosy by the time it arrives at TM.

I'd be interested to know what the average number of passengers currently using the 0733 and 0840 services is, and how many get on and off at each station.


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: John R on March 12, 2008, 21:30:00
Hmmm, that's a tricky one. I never get the 0733 (0752 from Nailsea) as it's just behind the HST. If for any reason it's ahead of the HST running late then I don't even bother to get it because it will be crush capacity on arrival, and no-one can get on.

It's purpose has been diluted somewhat since the HSTs started stopping at Worle, leaving only Milton, Bedminster and Parson St as calling points not served by the earlier train.

The 0840 from Weston used to be very busy after departing from Nailsea, and if a 143 would often be full and standing. However, the Voyager stops at Yatton and Nailsea have helped keep it less busy (but not, presumably, if it's a 153).

It's worth noting that since the infamous Dec 06 timetable change which introduced the additional HST arrival at around 0822, this service is now just about full on arrival, yet 15 months ago it didn't exist (and it was additional to existing services, not a replacement). In the early months it was quite quiet, but now there are about as many (60-70) waiting at Nailsea for it as for the earlier HST arrival just before 0800.  And there's a steady custom building up for the Voyager service, which means that is now standing room only north of Nailsea (except without fail I always find one person in an aisle seat with luggage on the window seat despite many standing..... >:()       




Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Chris from Nailsea on March 12, 2008, 21:45:46
This evening, the 1753 BTM to Nailsea was a one car 153 - the St Ives Bay Belle, slightly bizarrely!

I checked the live departure board before leaving the office, and it was reported as on time from Cardiff - but was 'overdue' at STJ. By the time I'd walked down to BTM, it was 'delayed' on the screens - always an ominous sign! In fact, rather than turning up on platform 8, it appeared from the opposite direction on platform 4!

Apparently, according to Phil, the excellent station announcer at BTM, services east of Bristol were being disrupted by a passenger being taken ill on a train at Stapleton Road, awaiting an ambulance.

And yes, it was rather cosy for us on that 153 this evening, John R!   ;D


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: John R on March 12, 2008, 21:48:10
Ouch! Glad I got the 1718. How many got left behind?


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Chris from Nailsea on March 12, 2008, 21:59:39
Actually, that was another slightly bizarre part of the experience this evening!  I think we got just about everyone on board - unless some poor souls were left still standing about hopefully on platform 8, not aware that the 1753 had sneaked up behind them on platform 4???

 :-X


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: John R on March 14, 2008, 19:51:03
The 0840 from Weston was also a 153 today (and earlier this week). Even at that time will be cosy by the time it arrives at TM.

I'd be interested to know what the average number of passengers currently using the 0733 and 0840 services is, and how many get on and off at each station.

So yesterday the 0733 arrived 12 mins late into Nailsea as a result of running on one engine. Twas a Cl143. At "right time" 6 people + me were waiting. Some may have delayed their arrival at the station knowing it was late (as I would have done if I wasn't researching the numbers). By the time it arrived around 20 got on, but some of those would have been early arrivals for the 0811.

8 got on and 3 off at Parson St.
7 on at Bedminster. Could tell how many got off.
Train was around 80% full on arrival, (so maybe 80 pax) but I'm guessing that was more than usual because of picking up early arrivals for the following service. 


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Lee on March 14, 2008, 21:18:04
The 0840 from Weston was also a 153 today (and earlier this week). Even at that time will be cosy by the time it arrives at TM.

I'd be interested to know what the average number of passengers currently using the 0733 and 0840 services is, and how many get on and off at each station.

So yesterday the 0733 arrived 12 mins late into Nailsea as a result of running on one engine. Twas a Cl143. At "right time" 6 people + me were waiting. Some may have delayed their arrival at the station knowing it was late (as I would have done if I wasn't researching the numbers). By the time it arrived around 20 got on, but some of those would have been early arrivals for the 0811.

8 got on and 3 off at Parson St.
7 on at Bedminster. Could tell how many got off.
Train was around 80% full on arrival, (so maybe 80 pax) but I'm guessing that was more than usual because of picking up early arrivals for the following service. 

Thanks John.


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: dog box on March 14, 2008, 21:50:29
lots of 143s seem to be poorly at the moment


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Chris from Nailsea on March 15, 2008, 20:50:47
Would I be right in saying that a 153 was covering a diagram in place of a poorly 143 today?

You may well be right there, Timmer.

I was chatting with someone from FGW recently, and he said the 143s are all pretty dire at present, due to them not having had much money spent on them for years. According to one of his chums who works in St Philip's Marsh, the door mechanisms are completely worn out, for example, and it's apparently taking 2 fitters a whole day to get one pair of doors working correctly!

From my experience on the Nailsea to BTM commute, I've occasionally seen the train staff have to give a door some 'friendly encouragement' to close properly, before we can depart!

 ::)


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: John R on March 15, 2008, 23:38:09
Sort of "Mike Tyson" friendly encouragement in my experience.


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Timmer on March 16, 2008, 07:27:44
The 142s seem to be doing better than the FGW 143s at the moment. Maybe SPM should send them down to Exeter for repair as the crew down there seem to be getting the most out of the 142s they were given.

It just goes to show how stretched the FGW local fleet is when a couple of sets are out of service short formed services become common as has been the case this pass week on cross Bristol services. Better than no service at all, but no fun if you end up travelling on the service that's short formed in the morning or evening peak.


Title: Re: Key Weston-Cardiff Service Class 153 Operated? (12/03/2008)
Post by: Timmer on March 16, 2008, 07:38:17
I was chatting with someone from FGW recently, and he said the 143s are all pretty dire at present, due to them not having had much money spent on them for years. According to one of his chums who works in St Philip's Marsh, the door mechanisms are completely worn out, for example, and it's apparently taking 2 fitters a whole day to get one pair of doors working correctly!

From my experience on the Nailsea to BTM commute, I've occasionally seen the train staff have to give a door some 'friendly encouragement' to close properly, before we can depart!

 ::)
Just about sums up all that's wrong with government policy when it comes to the railways, two fitters having to waste a day trying to get a clapped out piece of rubbish to work properly when it should have been replaced years ago.



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net