Great Western Coffee Shop

All across the Great Western territory => Fare's Fair => Topic started by: eXPassenger on February 11, 2018, 17:28:34



Title: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: eXPassenger on February 11, 2018, 17:28:34
As older people my wife and I have senior railcards and I have found an apparent bug in the way the GWR booking system handles multiple rail cards which results in the traveller being overcharged.

If I select a journey for 2 adults and specify 2 Senior Railcards then the planner shows 2 railcards but only gives me 1 discount.  If I then amend the search I can reduce the number of Senior railcards to 1 and add another line of 1 Senior railcard.  The planner now shows the correct double discount.  If I again amend the search the system has consolidated the 2 instances of the Senior railcard into 1 line with a quantity of 2.

I wonder how many people are not getting the full amount of railcard discount.


Title: Re: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: grahame on February 11, 2018, 17:46:18
As older people my wife and I have senior railcards and I have found an apparent bug in the way the GWR booking system handles multiple rail cards which results in the traveller being overcharged.

If I select a journey for 2 adults and specify 2 Senior Railcards then the planner shows 2 railcards but only gives me 1 discount.  If I then amend the search I can reduce the number of Senior railcards to 1 and add another line of 1 Senior railcard.  The planner now shows the correct double discount.  If I again amend the search the system has consolidated the 2 instances of the Senior railcard into 1 line with a quantity of 2.

I wonder how many people are not getting the full amount of railcard discount.

Gosh - that's naughty!   Just tried it out and it happened for me too - wonder if I have overlooked that in the past when buying tickets for my wife and I ...

Have you reported it?


Title: Re: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: eXPassenger on February 11, 2018, 18:26:53
As older people my wife and I have senior railcards and I have found an apparent bug in the way the GWR booking system handles multiple rail cards which results in the traveller being overcharged.

If I select a journey for 2 adults and specify 2 Senior Railcards then the planner shows 2 railcards but only gives me 1 discount.  If I then amend the search I can reduce the number of Senior railcards to 1 and add another line of 1 Senior railcard.  The planner now shows the correct double discount.  If I again amend the search the system has consolidated the 2 instances of the Senior railcard into 1 line with a quantity of 2.

I wonder how many people are not getting the full amount of railcard discount.

Gosh - that's naughty!   Just tried it out and it happened for me too - wonder if I have overlooked that in the past when buying tickets for my wife and I ...

Have you reported it?

Yes.  It will be interesting to see the response / time delay.


Title: Re: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: stuving on February 11, 2018, 18:42:47
That didn't happen just before Christmas, when I did just that - bought two tickets with two railcards, added and listed on the confirmation e-mail as such. And when I try the same booking now, entering the details on the landing page, it accepts cards=2 but shows cards=1 there, but offers me two tickets both at the railcard price. And if I click Amend the search box shows cards=2 as well. So are you sure the prices being quoted are wrong?


Title: Re: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: eXPassenger on February 11, 2018, 18:59:32
That didn't happen just before Christmas, when I did just that - bought two tickets with two railcards, added and listed on the confirmation e-mail as such. And when I try the same booking now, entering the details on the landing page, it accepts cards=2 but shows cards=1 there, but offers me two tickets both at the railcard price. And if I click Amend the search box shows cards=2 as well. So are you sure the prices being quoted are wrong?

Looking at Yatton to Paddington return at 9:40 on 9 March.  After selecting 2 adults, senior railcard x 2 I get the offer of Super Off Peak at £111.40.
If I amend the search, reduce the number of rail cards to 1 and use the + button to get a new line in which I insert Senior Railcard x 1 (Giving 2 lines, each of 1 Senior railcard).
The search now shows the cost of the Super Off Peak as £88.60.  The full price of this ticket for 2 adults is £134.20.


Title: Re: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: stuving on February 11, 2018, 19:23:01
Note that I had set the ralicards in the entry dialogue, and it worked. If I go into the amend dialogue, delete the railcards and the enter two there, I get what you describe - just one discount. that dialogue and the results page don't show how many cards they are allowing, so only the price tells you that.

If I amend an existing railcard entry to two, it works properly. Not only by selecting one, then two, but also by selecting three - which is rejected - and then two. So it appears to be a fault in that dialogue.


Title: Re: Apparent bug in GWR booking system
Post by: eXPassenger on March 02, 2018, 18:09:34
No reply to me but the bug appears to have been corrected.



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net