Title: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 12, 2016, 20:39:11 (http://www.wellho.net/pix/canthey.jpg)
a) Can they be programmed to display "the next train does not stop here - please stand back" b) Can they make announcements (over a limited area, of course) c) I've noticed "communication error" messages up a bit too often for my liking - though my main experience is of the Melksham machine. Also seen it at Saltash. Do others display this error message rather than train times very often? Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 12, 2016, 20:44:15 I was heartened to see the screen at Melksham working just before nine this morning.
Sadly my joy was short lived - it had failed by lunchtime. ??? Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: JayMac on November 12, 2016, 20:55:56 The screen at Newquay was showing the "Communication error" message on both days I was there earlier this week. I reported it on day 1.
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 12, 2016, 22:23:10 The speakers are quite loud. I assume an announcement could be made. They contain a phone line for the help point to connect. So dial the units telephone number and talk through it, assuming it auto answers.
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: JayMac on November 12, 2016, 22:37:26 Since coming across a list of Help Point numbers (which appear to be PSTN) I've been tempted to call one of them whilst nearby, to see what happens.
Fear that there might be some byelaw or other other law I'd be breaking has tempered my curiosity. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: broadgage on November 12, 2016, 22:56:06 Since coming across a list of Help Point numbers (which appear to be PSTN) I've been tempted to call one of them whilst nearby, to see what happens. Fear that there might be some byelaw or other other law I'd be breaking has tempered my curiosity. I would be tempted to try it ! Provided that you don't try anything obviously malicious or rude it would be very difficult to prove any wrongdoing. "it was a wrong number your honour" I doubt that you can actually talk to it with any result, probably data only. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Richard Fairhurst on November 12, 2016, 23:48:19 a) Can they be programmed to display "the next train does not stop here - please stand back" They're just web browsers with a mobile connection - they can in theory display anything you like. There's a central site for them with several pre-baked layouts, but showing something different should (in theory!) just require altering the code running on the server, rather than anything actually on the unit itself. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 13, 2016, 07:22:45 Perhaps they could alter the code so when in failure mode it shows the GWR logo rather than First Great Western....
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 13, 2016, 07:59:09 a) Can they be programmed to display "the next train does not stop here - please stand back" They're just web browsers with a mobile connection - they can in theory display anything you like. There's a central site for them with several pre-baked layouts, but showing something different should (in theory!) just require altering the code running on the server, rather than anything actually on the unit itself. I've taken a look through all the standard formats ... and none of them includes trains passing without stopping, I'm afraid. That data's not in the XML source either. They CAN display an extra messages added by 'control' (?) such as telling people that buses and taxis are on the way; that's not used as quickly and routinely as I would like, but it is there. For every case of "next train DOES NOT STOP" that would potentially be a lot of effort and I suspect the best solution would be a yellow line ... [[ should have noted - original question based on a case of someone straying rather near the platform edge ... getting a bit of a fright as an HST came though - "I thought all trains stopped here" ]] Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: ellendune on November 13, 2016, 08:53:00 The systems at larger stations have a "please stand back as the next train does not stop" message so there must be a code in that system. Is it a different system?
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Richard Fairhurst on November 13, 2016, 12:07:38 I've taken a look through all the standard formats ... and none of them includes trains passing without stopping, I'm afraid. That data's not in the XML source either. I believe that the HTML page sent to the screens, as currently specified, can be told to show a general warning in large text in the blue section at the top. Here's a local example right now: http://iris2.rail.co.uk/tiger/rendercis.asp?file=3053C6.xml (this may change by the time anyone clicks on the link, of course!). So GWR could configure this to say "Fast trains are passing through Melksham today without stopping - please stand back from the platform edge." But really, what I was getting at was more that the answer to "can they be programmed" is surely yes, they can, if GWR pay ATOS Worldline some money to do so. ;) (For those unaware what we're talking about, take a look at http://iris2.rail.co.uk/tiger/ - a departure board on your very own monitor!) Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: John R on November 13, 2016, 12:36:49 Going back to the issue that caused the question, I would have thought the driver of a fast through train should sound his horn if there are passengers close to the platform edge, or are heading in that direction. More so if the driver knows that the route is somewhat unusual, so passengers are less likely to be expecting the fast service.
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 13, 2016, 12:42:38 He/she did!
It is a bit of an optical illusion but an HST approaching from the south does not appear to be going that fast when it gets close to the platform at Melksham. In reality it is probably doing 40 to 60mph. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Bmblbzzz on November 13, 2016, 12:49:28 Yellow line: I thought every platform which fast trains pass without stopping, even occasionally, had one. I would have taken the absence of a yellow line to mean that all trains stop or pass slowly.
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 13, 2016, 12:52:50 Melksham hasn't yet....
(http://www.mbob.co.uk/rforum/melkhst.jpg) Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Bmblbzzz on November 13, 2016, 12:54:23 As for the screens themselves, they often seem to say only that they have no information "today" due to a data failure. Today seems to be a lot of days.
The design of the machines is somewhat misleading too; why is the emergency communication button green rather than, say, red? Or why does it not have some recognizable symbol on it? A couple of times my son, when he was small, pressed the green button thinking it was the "tell me when the next train's coming" button. I'm sure the green colour, as well as the prominent position, misled him. The operator who responded – seems to be a railway person not a 999 operator – was quite understanding; apart from the time they didn't respond at all, which was good at the time but kind of worrying, really. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: paul7575 on November 13, 2016, 13:09:45 Yellow line: I thought every platform which fast trains pass without stopping, even occasionally, had one. I would have taken the absence of a yellow line to mean that all trains stop or pass slowly. A yellow line is only actually required if passenger trains pass at speeds over 100 mph, and freight at speeds over 60 mph, as per the published rail group standards. http://www.rssb.co.uk/rgs/standards/GIRT7016%20Iss%205.pdf The vast majority of yellow lines you see are additional to the laid down rules, and absence of a line should actually be the normal situation. The boy who cried wolf... Paul Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 13, 2016, 13:10:44 Yellow line: I thought every platform which fast trains pass without stopping, even occasionally, had one. I would have taken the absence of a yellow line to mean that all trains stop or pass slowly. There are threshold(s) above which, I believe, it's mandatory. As Melksham's on a curve and HSTs pass at only around a half of their top speed, and as passenger numbers are very low (or were), there is no yellow line. We did ask for one, but the request was turned down - not on the cost of painting it, but on the grounds of the increased maintenance costs to keep it clean. With three trains an hour on recent Saturdays, two non-stop, and plentiful people gathering for a stopping service which typically arrives just under 20 minutes after an express has passed through, GWR / Network Rail may wish to reconsider this. Both organisations were represented at a site meeting at Melksham Station on 17th October and although the focus was looking ahead to future passenger numbers and trains, current issues including safety concerns were mentioned. Added ... A yellow line is only actually required if passenger trains pass at speeds over 100 mph, and freight at speeds over 60 mph, as per the published rail group standards. http://www.rssb.co.uk/rgs/standards/GIRT7016%20Iss%205.pdf The vast majority of yellow lines you see are additional to the laid down rules, and absence of a line should actually be the normal situation. The boy who cried wolf... Paul Thanks Paul - confirms they are not required at Melksham Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: IndustryInsider on November 13, 2016, 13:12:45 Any temporary loss of signal seems to show the 'out of order' screen, so I've seen one working one minute, not the next, and then come back on again. I'm not sure having a 'next train not stopping' message would be a great deal of use as they have nowhere near the same impact as the orange LED Next Train Indicator screens which can be seen from thirty or forty metres away. Though perhaps if they could be configured to make an announcement to such an effect on the really small stations it might be beneficial?
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 13, 2016, 13:17:23 I could understand the argument about the cost of maintaining the yellow line if it was in isolation, however there is also a white line which presumably also needs upkeep. Would the incremental cost of maintaining the yellow line be so great if done at the same time as the white?
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: chuffed on November 13, 2016, 13:20:19 All you would have needed in maintenance costs for any sort of line (yellow or white) in Ian Allen Spotter days would have been 3 small boys in short trousers, a chilly day, and a bottle of Tizer each !
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 13, 2016, 13:27:41 I could understand the argument about the cost of maintaining the yellow line if it was in isolation, however there is also a white line which presumably also needs upkeep. Would the incremental cost of maintaining the yellow line be so great if done at the same time as the white? The white lines are "road side" and were painted by Wiltshire Council. Most of them are on the council's land, but the final 8 feet or so to the station gate are actually on Network Rail land - as is the front half of each of the car parking spaces also (re) painted by Wiltshire Council. So presumably it would be a different maintenance team? All you would have needed in maintenance costs for any sort of line (yellow or white) in Ian Allen Spotter days would have been 3 small boys in short trousers, a chilly day, and a bottle of Tizer each ! But these days you need professional raimen certified to work nearer the tracks than passengers / volunteers are allowed until the train has pulled in. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 13, 2016, 13:38:21 I was thinking of the white line on the platform edge.
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 13, 2016, 13:40:54 Going back to the issue that caused the question, I would have thought the driver of a fast through train should sound his horn if there are passengers close to the platform edge, or are heading in that direction. More so if the driver knows that the route is somewhat unusual, so passengers are less likely to be expecting the fast service. He/she did! It is a bit of an optical illusion but an HST approaching from the south does not appear to be going that fast when it gets close to the platform at Melksham. In reality it is probably doing 40 to 60mph. Approaching from the south, trains to round a curve (that's where they have slower), under a bridge, and behind a building which is about 2 metres from the old platform edge. They then "burst" upon the platform. With the bridge and building in the way, a sounded horn appears distant and muffled, and isn't going to be associate with the appearance of a train within seconds. And the presence of the building (and fence and bushes between the building and the platform edge) reduces visibility of passengers to train and of train (driver) to people on the platform. I was thinking of the white line on the platform edge. Oh gosh yes - hadn't really though of that as a line! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 13, 2016, 17:22:03 Yellow line: I thought every platform which fast trains pass without stopping, even occasionally, had one. I would have taken the absence of a yellow line to mean that all trains stop or pass slowly. Truro is the only station in cornwall with yellow lines. Many stations are missed on various services and of course ECS and freight. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: stuving on November 13, 2016, 17:43:07 And then there's the Design Standards for Accessible Railway Stations (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/425977/design-standards-accessible-stations.pdf), that franchisees have to sign up to. A mixture of provisions from the PRM TSI, national standards and laws, and its own guides to good practice. Most only come into play for new work, variously defined.
For displays it has a lot to say about visibility, including the need for low-level ones, which the help points should address. For help points it is more concerned that there should actually be helpful help in response of the button press. On the design of the box itself, it includes: Quote M1. Code of Practice guidance f. Operators should ensure that: • the help point can be located easily; • the location does not impede pedestrian traffic; • controls are within comfortable reach range; • the force required to operate the controls is kept to a minimum and that controls are palm-operable; • the buttons contrast well with the background and that their function is described both in text and tactile form; • the buttons have a minimum diameter of 20 mm; • the person providing the help can be heard (localised acoustic consideration); and • a visual indicator lamp indicates to a hearing impaired person that their call has been answered. On platforms, the TSI has a lot about how much space is needed for two wheelchairs to pass safely, and what obstructions in the desirable width are acceptable. On deliniations, visible and tactile, the TSI's requirements: Quote S1.European standards ... are followed by several items of guidance:7. The danger area of a platform commences at the rail side edge of the platform and is defined as the area where passengers are not allowed to stand when trains are passing or arriving. 8. The illuminance level of the external areas of the station shall be sufficient to facilitate way finding and to highlight the changes of level, doors and entrances. 9.The boundary of the danger area, furthest from the rail side edge of the platform, shall have a visual marking and tactile walking surface indicators. 10. The visual marking shall be a contrasting, slip-resistant, warning line with a minimum width of 100 mm. 11. Tactile walking surface indicators can be one of the two types: • an attention pattern indicating a hazard at the boundary of the danger area • a guiding pattern indicating a path of travel at the safe side of the platform 12. The material at the rail side edge of the platform shall contrast with the darkness of the gap. This material shall be slip resistant. 13. The end of the platform shall either be fitted with a barrier that prevents public access or shall have a visual marking and tactile walking surface indicators with an attention pattern indicating a hazard. Quote S1. Platforms – platform design (... and yes, that last one isn't listed as a UK standard.)e. The appropriate tactile surface should be installed along the entire length of a platform when any rebuilding or resurfacing takes place. See Guidance on the Use of Tactile Paving Surfaces for further guidance. f. Where the tactile surface is installed on an island platform, it should be on both faces of the island platform. It should never be installed on one face and not the other. g. The platform edge tactile warning surface can be of any colour, except red, and the colour should provide a good contrast with the surrounding paved area. h. The tactile surface should be 400 mm deep, extend the full length of the platform, and be laid parallel to, and immediately behind, the platform edge coper, where this is 760 mm from the platform edge. Platforms that are only partially installed with tactile strips should be avoided. m. Where the permissible or enhanced permissible speed on the adjacent line is greater than 100 mph, a yellow line should be provided on the platform, together with warning signs. The yellow line shall be positioned so that people standing immediately behind the line are at least 1500 mm away from the platform edge. If Melksham gets a proper-sized platform, this stuff would presumably come into play. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 13, 2016, 18:00:34 Yellow line: I thought every platform which fast trains pass without stopping, even occasionally, had one. I would have taken the absence of a yellow line to mean that all trains stop or pass slowly. Truro is the only station in cornwall with yellow lines. Many stations are missed on various services and of course ECS and freight. Now if the platform at Melksham is rebuilt could this style be adopted and be low upkeep? (http://www.mbob.co.uk/rforum/nqyyel.jpg) Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 13, 2016, 18:17:58 If Melksham gets a proper-sized platform, this stuff would presumably come into play. Yes. Oh - sorry to give such a short answer to such a long reply ... but a planned platform extension would be to modern standard, and that means the current platform has to have the same standards too. It starts with the platform requiring to slope away from the track and not towards it, and for the height of the platform at train edge being raised to a reasonable level. Unfortunately, although these two adjustments are in opposite directions, they're not equal and opposite, so then there's the question of levels at the station entrance ... A tactile strip is part of the spec ... and once that's in, it will perform the same function as a yellow line in reminding people to keep back. So a yellow line 'in the meantime' might be a bit of paint and no long term maintenance? Truro is the only station in cornwall with yellow lines. Many stations are missed on various services and of course ECS and freight. How many have tactile stuff? Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 13, 2016, 18:23:20 Yellow line: I thought every platform which fast trains pass without stopping, even occasionally, had one. I would have taken the absence of a yellow line to mean that all trains stop or pass slowly. Truro is the only station in cornwall with yellow lines. Many stations are missed on various services and of course ECS and freight. Now if the platform at Melksham is rebuilt could this style be adopted and be low upkeep? (http://www.mbob.co.uk/rforum/nqyyel.jpg) I forgot about Newquay, probably due to all those high speed through trains. To answer Grahame the stations I've seen staffed are Penzance St erth, redruth, Truro, st Austell, Par (am only) Bodmin and liskeard. The rest unstaffed and also the ones that get most non stop services Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 13, 2016, 18:41:35 To answer Grahame the stations I've seen staffed are Penzance St erth, redruth, Truro, st Austell, Par (am only) Bodmin and liskeard. The rest unstaffed and also the ones that get most non stop services Err - I said "tactile stuff" meaning those bobbly lighter coloured stone panels ... not tactile staff ;D (Very interesting to know which stations are manned though!) Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Chris from Nailsea on November 13, 2016, 22:19:25 How many have tactile stuff? To be fair to richwarwicker (and knowing grahame's trademark typing so well), I too assumed that grahame was probably asking, "How many have actual staff?" ::) :D ;D Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: grahame on November 14, 2016, 07:01:19 How many have tactile stuff? To be fair to richwarwicker (and knowing grahame's trademark typing so well), I too assumed that grahame was probably asking, "How many have actual staff?" ::) :D ;D Totally agreed - very much looked like one of my smelling mistakes - sorry chaps! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: chuffed on November 14, 2016, 07:42:36 Tactile staff ? ? ?
Aren't they the ones who occupy certain positions at Bristol Temple Meads/Paddington..... who specialise in rubbing a certain esteemed member of this forum, up the wrong way ??! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 14, 2016, 08:14:59 How many have tactile stuff? To be fair to richwarwicker (and knowing grahame's trademark typing so well), I too assumed that grahame was probably asking, "How many have actual staff?" ::) :D ;D Totally agreed - very much looked like one of my smelling mistakes - sorry chaps! Not helped by me having a few beverages after I'd refereed the Plymouth Albion Ladies rugby match yesterday afternoon I'm sure! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Bmblbzzz on November 14, 2016, 10:06:04 Clearly there has to be a minimum speed for a train to be considered as high speed for yellow-line purposes (I remember seeing one for the first time in the late '70s at Stroud when some {or all?} of the HSTs from Cheltenham to Paddington went straight through) but I didn't know there was a frequency and passengers-on-the-platform consideration too.
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Jason on November 14, 2016, 11:40:03 Err - I said "tactile stuff" meaning those bobbly lighter coloured stone panels ... not tactile staff ;D (Very interesting to know which stations are manned though!) That stuff that's absolutely lethal when it's icy Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 14, 2016, 11:58:33 How many have tactile stuff? To be fair to richwarwicker (and knowing grahame's trademark typing so well), I too assumed that grahame was probably asking, "How many have actual staff?" ::) :D ;D Totally agreed - very much looked like one of my smelling mistakes - sorry chaps! Not helped by me having a few beverages after I'd refereed the Plymouth Albion Ladies rugby match yesterday afternoon I'm sure! Still it was a busy game by the sound of it with a 49-33 scoreline. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: lordgoata on November 14, 2016, 12:42:22 Err - I said "tactile stuff" meaning those bobbly lighter coloured stone panels ... not tactile staff ;D (Very interesting to know which stations are manned though!) That stuff that's absolutely lethal when it's icy It doesn't even need to be icy, just wet makes it as bad as sheet ice anyway! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 14, 2016, 13:08:57 How many have tactile stuff? To be fair to richwarwicker (and knowing grahame's trademark typing so well), I too assumed that grahame was probably asking, "How many have actual staff?" ::) :D ;D Totally agreed - very much looked like one of my smelling mistakes - sorry chaps! Not helped by me having a few beverages after I'd refereed the Plymouth Albion Ladies rugby match yesterday afternoon I'm sure! Still it was a busy game by the sound of it with a 49-33 scoreline. Yes very busy game. Lovely to ref mind. Both teams looked excellent in attack. Managed not to use the sin bin. Albions pitch is a little disappointing considering their men's standard. Cut up very easily and very muddy considering we haven't had any bad weather. Plenty of photos posted through the 'visitor post' section on Plymouth Albion ladies Facebook. Bet you can't guess which one is me! ;D Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: JayMac on November 14, 2016, 14:37:26 Bet you can't guess which one is me! ;D Not hard to miss amongst the ladies. Particularly with the very pink jersey and socks! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: TaplowGreen on November 14, 2016, 14:46:56 How many have tactile stuff? To be fair to richwarwicker (and knowing grahame's trademark typing so well), I too assumed that grahame was probably asking, "How many have actual staff?" ::) :D ;D Totally agreed - very much looked like one of my smelling mistakes - sorry chaps! Not helped by me having a few beverages after I'd refereed the Plymouth Albion Ladies rugby match yesterday afternoon I'm sure! Still it was a busy game by the sound of it with a 49-33 scoreline. Yes very busy game. Lovely to ref mind. Both teams looked excellent in attack. Managed not to use the sin bin. Albions pitch is a little disappointing considering their men's standard. Cut up very easily and very muddy considering we haven't had any bad weather. Plenty of photos posted through the 'visitor post' section on Plymouth Albion ladies Facebook. Bet you can't guess which one is me! ;D It's a great shame they left Beacon Park, many happy memories of playing there. Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 14, 2016, 15:59:18 Bet you can't guess which one is me! ;D Not hard to miss amongst the ladies. Particularly with the very pink jersey and socks! My reserve kit. The main kit is a shade of green, it was bad enough having dark green against lime green without me clashing as well. Neither club possessed a reserve strip Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: JayMac on November 14, 2016, 17:18:52 I remember at school if you turned up without the proper kit you had to do games in your underwear...
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 14, 2016, 17:26:31 Doubt we could apply that to ladies rugby let alone the referees. ;D
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: TaplowGreen on November 14, 2016, 17:36:35 I remember at school if you turned up without the proper kit you had to do games in your underwear... .......blimey which school was that? Eton? :DTitle: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: LiskeardRich on November 14, 2016, 17:39:13 Doubt we could apply that to ladies rugby let alone the referees. ;D Now wouldn't that be a good idea! I have around a dozen referee shirts, but only 3 are short sleeves and I hate long sleeve! 2 of the short sleeve are green! Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Chris from Nailsea on November 14, 2016, 17:49:27 One of the many things I enjoy about the Coffee Shop forum is reading how we can get from this ...
(http://www.wellho.net/pix/canthey.jpg) ... to discussing a requirement for ladies to play rugby in their underwear in just three pages of posts. ;) :D ;D Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: bobm on November 14, 2016, 21:41:38 Thankfully he only posted the "before" photo and not the "after"...... ;D ;D
Title: Re: Questions about these screens ... Post by: Bmblbzzz on December 01, 2016, 13:45:28 More yellow lines. Found this on youtube:
https://youtu.be/7KSZAsHXYxQ This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net |