Title: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: chrisr_75 on September 09, 2015, 13:48:42 Full article from BBC news here http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-34195309 (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-34195309) Top 10 most crowded trains 2014: 1. 04:22 Glasgow Central to Manchester Airport 2. 16:00 Manchester Airport to Edinburgh 3. 06:31 Reading to London Paddington 4. 07:57 London Heathrow to London Paddington 5. 07:02 Reading to London Paddington 6. 06:35 Caterham to Victoria Central 7. 07:24 Brighton to Bedford 8. 18:00 Manchester Airport to Edinburgh 9. 07:32 Woking to London Waterloo 10. 07:02 Woking to London Waterloo Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on September 09, 2015, 20:00:34 Quote The DfT warns that there are problems with the reliability of the figures, in particular that standard class passengers were counted on a single day that is not necessarily representative. Salt. Pinch. To be read with ... Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: LiskeardRich on September 09, 2015, 20:24:20 The 0422 Glasgow Central to Manchester airport I assume is only crowded at the Manchester end.
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on September 09, 2015, 20:36:43 The 0422 Glasgow Central to Manchester airport I assume is only crowded at the Manchester end. Yep ... Quote Top of the list is a train originating in Scotland, the 04:22 TransPennine Express service from Glasgow Central to Manchester Airport. The time when the most overcrowding was noticed was clearly closer to the 08:47 arrival time in Manchester, when commuters joined the route. At its peak, 355 people were counted on a train designed for 191. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: LiskeardRich on September 09, 2015, 20:50:29 The 0422 Glasgow Central to Manchester airport I assume is only crowded at the Manchester end. Yep ... Quote Top of the list is a train originating in Scotland, the 04:22 TransPennine Express service from Glasgow Central to Manchester Airport. The time when the most overcrowding was noticed was clearly closer to the 08:47 arrival time in Manchester, when commuters joined the route. At its peak, 355 people were counted on a train designed for 191. Thanks for comfirming. I was starting to imagine the people of Glasgow all get up at 4 am. ;D Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: JayMac on September 09, 2015, 21:26:24 The 0422 Glasgow Central to Manchester airport I assume is only crowded at the Manchester end. Perhaps the Preston and Wigan commuters should consider moving to Glasgow to guarantee a seat! ;) :P ;D Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: chrisr_75 on September 10, 2015, 01:03:21 Quote The DfT warns that there are problems with the reliability of the figures, in particular that standard class passengers were counted on a single day that is not necessarily representative. Salt. Pinch. To be read with ... Indeed! I wondered how long it'd take before someone spotted that ;D Not sure why DfT bother to release Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: IndustryInsider on September 10, 2015, 10:39:07 Not sure why DfT bother to release Totally agree. A complete waste of time in this 'one random day' format, and just gives a licence to the press to print negative and misleading stories. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: paul7575 on September 10, 2015, 12:07:58 Don't they make a 'rod for their own back' in some cases though. If that TPE service from Glasgow to Man Picc is only crowded for the last few miles, why not just put it in the list as the 07:44 from Preston, or 07:56 from Wigan, or whatever?
Paul Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: eightf48544 on September 10, 2015, 12:14:15 I would imagine this overcrowding for a small part of the journey also applies to
2. 16:00 Manchester Airport to Edinburgh 8. 18:00 Manchester Airport to Edinburgh Manchester Pic/Oxford Road Wigan/Preston Plus: 4. 07:57 London Heathrow to London Paddington which is probably empty stock from Heathrow. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: paul7575 on September 10, 2015, 13:21:04 Of course the problem is limited to the ends of the routes.
That's the problem with the media summary of these annual figures going straight for the basic 'top ten' origins and destinations; the DfT's source document explains exactly where and why each of the ten services has the problem, and it isn't in Scotland. In this case it is because of electrification changing the routeing of the trains through the Greater Manchester area from Bolton to Wigan, and the resulting change to timing of the first call north of Oxford Rd. Quote 1. 04:22 service from Glasgow Central to Manchester Airport (load factor 186%, 164 passengers in excess of its capacity of 191) Capacity is based on seats only. Service has first class. The three TransPennine Express (TPE) services appearing in the current ^top 10^ list are now routing via Wigan rather than Bolton. Previously the most crowded part of the journey took only 13 minutes from Manchester Oxford Road and was therefore out of scope for inclusion in the list as a standing allowance was included. Overall, TPE has seen significant growth on the Anglo-Scottish route which offers key long distance leisure trips from Manchester to Edinburgh/Glasgow, alongside a large take up of customers travelling to/from Manchester for commuting purposes. Contributing to this increase has been the introduction of new electric rolling stock on all Anglo-Scottish services route via Wigan which has brought about significant journey time reductions. Low-priced Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) tickets for 20 mile journeys have also contributed to the increase. TPE has now amended Advance Purchase prices in an attempt to move longer distance customers on to services which do not operate in the peak. 2. 16:00 service from Manchester Airport to Edinburgh (load factor 185%, 162 passengers in excess of its capacity of 191) Capacity is based on seats only. Service has first class. See note at 1 above. 8. 18:00 service from Manchester Airport to Edinburgh (load factor 161%, 116 passengers in excess of its capacity of 191) Capacity is based on seats only. Service has first class. See note at 1 above. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/459321/top-10-crowded-trains-2014-autumn.pdf Paul Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: IndustryInsider on September 11, 2015, 09:24:47 Don't they make a 'rod for their own back' in some cases though. If that TPE service from Glasgow to Man Picc is only crowded for the last few miles, why not just put it in the list as the 07:44 from Preston, or 07:56 from Wigan, or whatever? Indeed they do, and it allows journalists who are either uninformed or quite happy to mislead to give some quite ridiculous headlines such as the 'Glasgow has worst train' sub-headline in yesterday's Metro. 'The one you really want to avoid' the Metro goes on, when, in reality, anyone who gets the 04:22 Glasgow to Manchester Airport from Glasgow would probably be hard-pressed to find anyone else in their carriage for the first couple of hours! Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: TaplowGreen on September 11, 2015, 15:43:24 The 0422 Glasgow Central to Manchester airport I assume is only crowded at the Manchester end. Yep ... Quote Top of the list is a train originating in Scotland, the 04:22 TransPennine Express service from Glasgow Central to Manchester Airport. The time when the most overcrowding was noticed was clearly closer to the 08:47 arrival time in Manchester, when commuters joined the route. At its peak, 355 people were counted on a train designed for 191. Thanks for comfirming. I was starting to imagine the people of Glasgow all get up at 4 am. ;D Having had quite a few nights out in Glasgow, I can confirm that most of the locals are only just getting home at 4 am! That Buckie tonic works wonders!!! ;) Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: hoover50 on September 11, 2015, 16:29:27 I would be interested to know how many carriages these services have? ???
We are constantly being told there is a national shortage of carriages which is complete rubbish! >:( There are a number of Mk2D, Mk2E, Mk2F and Mk3 carriages in storage or owned by small operators and barely used. These can be hauled by hired-in ETH fitted class 37, 47 and 67 locos. Just look at the Cumbrian Coast services and also the Norwich - Lowestoft/Great Yarmouth services to see how common sense can prevail. ;D Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on September 11, 2015, 17:16:25 I would be interested to know how many carriages these services have? ??? The information on which the article is based is online [here] (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/459321/top-10-crowded-trains-2014-autumn.pdf) and included that data. Thanks to Paul7755 for providing that link. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: a-driver on September 11, 2015, 19:00:18 We are constantly being told there is a national shortage of carriages which is complete rubbish! >:( There are a number of Mk2D, Mk2E, Mk2F and Mk3 carriages in storage or owned by small operators and barely used. These can be hauled by hired-in ETH fitted class 37, 47 and 67 locos. Just look at the Cumbrian Coast services and also the Norwich - Lowestoft/Great Yarmouth services to see how common sense can prevail. ;D Unfortunately it's not quite as simply and straightforward as that! Bit easier for the Cumbrian Coast services and Lowestoft/Great Yarmouth as they are on the doorstep of DRS who supply the rolling stock. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on July 27, 2016, 15:20:30 Expecting the annual update on this one very soon ... I wonder how it will have changed!
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on July 29, 2016, 05:40:23 Hasn't hit the headlines as in previous years - but The Standard (http://www.standard.co.uk/news/transport/rush-hour-hell-faced-by-londoners-on-capitals-most-overcrowded-train-lines-a3306656.html) picked it up and so did The Daily Mail (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3713597/Cattle-class-getting-worse-Railways-crisis-point-trains-carry-TWICE-people-should.html?ITO=1490&ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490)
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: TaplowGreen on July 29, 2016, 08:15:13 Whatever it is, I can tell you what the response from the rail industry will be, the same as always - "Manana Manana" ::)
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on July 29, 2016, 11:41:53 No.10 on that list, 06:15 Edinburgh to Manchester has a load factor of 161%, how close is the 17:36 from Swindon to making that list? :)
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: John R on July 29, 2016, 17:36:55 Quite a way. Grahame's last report on the 1736 was 96 on a 75 seat unit, so 121%. Would need to squeeze on another 25 before it becomes top of the charts! :o. Hopefully it will be a 2 car unit before then!
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on July 29, 2016, 18:59:45 Quite a way. Grahame's last report on the 1736 was 96 on a 75 seat unit, so 121%. Would need to squeeze on another 25 before it becomes top of the charts! :o. Hopefully it will be a 2 car unit before then! Most we've managed is 119 ;D ... that was on a match Saturday before Christmas though Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: ChrisB on July 29, 2016, 21:41:32 The Independent's online article (can't post a link from my iphone easily) has a photo of Paddington saying trains from there feature in the list - well, they must be well down & definitely NOT in the top 10 any longer. Credit to GWR for that. But really, don't tar a station with lazy photos!
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on July 30, 2016, 08:50:59 Yes, the 07:34 from Didcot was an Adelante when the spring 2015 results came out, by the Autumn however this had been changed to an HST.
One thing about that 07:34 though, it didn't actually exist up until about 2-3 years ago when it was put in as an additional train to ease overcrowding on services either side of it. So I'm guessing the spring 2016 survey has already been done, and we'll get those results this time next year, how on earth can it take so long? They publish the top 10 with a footnote on most of them explaining due to changes in the last year these services are unlikely to be in the top 10 now. Seems a bit pointless really. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: IndustryInsider on July 30, 2016, 08:54:29 Seems a bit pointless really. That just about sums it up perfectly. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on July 30, 2016, 09:55:32 Seems a bit pointless really. That just about sums it up perfectly.There is huge sense in balancing trains - having longer trains on busier services. But this data is so late, so selective, and such a tiny sample that it does verge on the useless when published. Most train operators know perfectly well which are the busy / overcrowded services and do 'what they can' long before publication - and looking not just at the top 10, but much wider and on different days of the week and different weather conditions too. What they might not be 100% familiar with is *why* it's those particular trains that are busy / quiet, especially where the reasons are off-rail - but that's a long way from the story. And of course busyness varies along the route. Think we discussed that last year; I was talking to a journalist the other day looking for a Wiltshire story in the (over)crowding on Thames Valley suburban services. "What if someone's travelling from Swindon / Chippenham and changing onto that train at Reading to get to Maidenhaed or Slough?". Yes, but the peak crowding is in the inner suburbs - and our Wiltshire passenger will be getting off as the peak crush gets on! Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: stuving on July 30, 2016, 12:43:02 I can't see a link above to the
Both sets of data come from internal management information within TOCs, from a variety of methods and timescales. I'm sure that applies to the totality of data supplied to DfT, not just the top ten trains. It may be that the trains where loading is an issue get better monitoring, while it's the little-used ones that get an occasional single day's numbers recorded. Then again it may not. GWR disappear from the list between spring and autumn 2015. I'm not really sure why, but I suspect it was a few minor changes targeted specifically at those crowded services in the earlier list. You can call that gaming the system, or equally the result of this little bit of DfT "amplification" speeding up a TOC's response to passenger concerns. As you will have found out if you go looking for loading data online, these are not available as they need to be protected as commercial secrets. Which is nonsense, of course they don't! Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on July 30, 2016, 13:11:47 Quote GWR disappear from the list between spring and autumn 2015. I'm not really sure why I did explain why above, on one of the GWR services anyway. I feel GWR have done a very good job over the past few years utilising the stock they have available to them, which includes making more use of the HSTs. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: grahame on July 31, 2016, 21:12:36 From Chronicle Live (http://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/newcastles-trains-least-overcrowded-country-11685472?)
Quote Newcastle's trains are some of the least overcrowded in the country - what do you think? There were no peak services into Newcastle carrying more passengers than they were designed to, where as 94,000 London-bound passengers had to stand Rail passengers in Newcastle are some of the best off when it comes to overcrowding. During peak morning hours, Newcastle has some of the smallest levels of overcrowding on train services compared to the rest of the country. According to data from the Department of Transport, no train services arriving in Newcastle between 8am and 9am had more passengers than they were designed to carry. In comparison, nearly half of all trains arriving in London at the same time were filled above capacity - and 30 per cent of all passengers had to stand. None of the train operators in Newcastle had problems with serious overcrowding, although TransPennine Express did see 10 per cent of its passengers standing on services that arrived into the city between 7am and 10am. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on July 31, 2017, 07:50:10 The usual annual overcrowded trains list was released the other day.
Here (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/633080/top-10-overcrowded-train-services-england-and-wales-autumn-2016.csv/preview) is the top 10 list. Whilst here (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/633081/top-10-overcrowded-train-services-england-and-wales-spring-and-autumn-2016.pdf) is the link to the usual PDF that explains how the list is already out of date. Quote 7 London London Paddington 17:18 Great Western Railway 17:18 Quote 7. 17:18 London Paddington to Oxford (Great Western Railway) At the time of this count this service was operated as a 5 car train, however, the service in now operated as an 8 car train and capacity has significantly increased. Additional services will be introduced in January 2018. In the longer term the Elizabeth Line (Crossrail) will provide additional capacity on this route, which should result in a shift in demand on parallel services. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Gordon the Blue Engine on July 31, 2017, 09:10:38 The usual annual overcrowded trains list was released the other day. Here (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/633080/top-10-overcrowded-train-services-england-and-wales-autumn-2016.csv/preview) is the top 10 list. Whilst here (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/633081/top-10-overcrowded-train-services-england-and-wales-spring-and-autumn-2016.pdf) is the link to the usual PDF that explains how the list is already out of date. Quote 7 London London Paddington 17:18 Great Western Railway 17:18 Quote 7. 17:18 London Paddington to Oxford (Great Western Railway) At the time of this count this service was operated as a 5 car train, however, the service in now operated as an 8 car train and capacity has significantly increased. Additional services will be introduced in January 2018. In the longer term the Elizabeth Line (Crossrail) will provide additional capacity on this route, which should result in a shift in demand on parallel services. Has DfT got a bit confused here? 1718 Padd – Oxford is not an 8 car train, but of course there is now additional capacity to Maidenhead around that time from the new Class 387 service. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: John R on July 31, 2017, 09:10:56 It does seem rather ridiculous that the survey covers services in the spring of 2016, as well as the autumn. Why not publish the survey twice a year, otherwise it is always going to appear outdated.
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: IndustryInsider on July 31, 2017, 09:40:05 Yes they've made a mistake. It's a 5-car Turbo now rather than a 5-Car 180 so a slight improvement in seat numbers but not seat comfort.
This silly survey has provided an easy story for the press of Oxford with one reporting that Oxford commuters were being forced to catch one of the busiest trains in the country when in reality they'd get the 17:22 out of Paddington (seats almost always available) or the 17:18 out of Marylebone rather than the semi-fast 17:18. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on July 31, 2017, 09:58:24 17:18 stops at Twyford from September as well which could make it even busier
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Gordon the Blue Engine on August 02, 2017, 18:30:26 Presumably calling at Twyford because the present 1711 Padd – Henley becomes an EMU to Maidenhead only. I’m not sure that passengers for Maidenhead will be tempted to use the 1711 any more than they are now, as it leaves Padd earlier than the 1718 Padd – Oxford and arrives at Maidenhead later.
Which means that the hopelessly overcrowded 1718 Padd – Oxford will now gain all or many of the Twyford and Henley passengers who currently use the 1711 Padd - Henley. Is it too much to hope that the current 5 cars may become 6 or even more, even if that means detaching the rear unit at Reading as 6 cars is max for stoppers to Didcot? This of course assumes that Maidenhead and Twyford can do 8 cars, which I think they can but am not certain. Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on August 02, 2017, 18:46:26 Twyford pax still have the 17:06 though
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Gordon the Blue Engine on August 02, 2017, 19:00:49 Yes indeed, with a 2 minute connection for the Henley service. Good luck to them!
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Adelante_CCT on August 02, 2017, 19:21:54 Lots of people use this, 17:28 arrival, 17:31 departure to Henley. The 17:06 is usually full and standing and empties out considerably at Twyford, many heading straight for the shuttle
Title: Re: BBC - Top 10 most crowded trains named Post by: Gordon the Blue Engine on August 03, 2017, 21:00:40 Looking at Recent Train Times, this connection works about 4 working days out of 5. Depending on your expectations, this may be good, acceptable, or bad.
I wonder how much running up and down footbridge steps there is at Twyford, which we all know is very naughty (seriously, this is a significant H & S issue). I remember when the principle down commuter trains in the evening would run into Twyford on the UR, thus giving a cross-platform change to the Henley service. I think in those days it was done to save the gentlemen from Henley having to negotiate the footbridge, but there are useful safety benefits in reducing footfall by rushing passengers over footbridges. I accept that the UR is probably too busy nowadays to allow this to-day. So you need to think about "unrushed" connections and footbridge design to minimise the risk of tripping etc accidents when passengers are using the footbridge to get to the Henley platform. This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net |