Title: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: johoare on July 11, 2013, 18:50:37 When I got off my train from Reading at Maidenhead earlier the 17.40 from Paddington to Oxford was at the next platform.. When I glanced up at the main board, underneath that train it said (and I've never seen this before) "Train reported to be full and standing"..
Erm.. well yes...that is all well and good telling people waiting at Maidenhead that.. And I've been on that train (a class 180) so I know it's true. But it's irrelevant information as a lot of those people causing the train to be full will have been getting off at Maidenhead anyway as it's one of our fast (first stop Maidenhead) trains.. ::) Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: Super Guard on July 11, 2013, 22:07:46 We are asked to report when trains are F&S, and as a 180 has a TM on board, then he/she has done this - and when we report F&S, the CIS team will sometimes put it on the screens.
Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: johoare on July 11, 2013, 22:18:55 Yep I guessed that.. Just strange on that train.. or in fact any train that is first stop Maidenhead in the evening peak... Because:
1) They will ALL be full and standing 2) The people waiting at Maidenhead don't need to know that as it won't be by the time they get on :-) I was just interested as I've not seen it before and I've commuted for more years than I like to remember ;D Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: Busboy W1 on July 11, 2013, 22:38:35 As Super Guard commented F.G.W Towers are rather keen on the idea of reporting wether a train is F&S or not and also the reduction in coaches for many reasons.This is then relayed towards the CIS which control the majority of screens.
Although I must say the trains in question that are operated (usually) by a 180 this being 1D53 17:18 and 1D69 19:18 are usually F&S until at least Pangbourne and its a struggle for people boarding at TWY let alone Maidenhead International so the signs appearing seem fit for purpose. :D Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: johoare on July 11, 2013, 22:42:45 Well having been on this train and getting off at Maidenhead I know that the percentage of people getting on there is minimal to those getting off.. So if it's still full and standing after Maidenhead then I'm not quite sure why... Unless it's boarding on/definitely dangerous conditions until Maidenhead I guess.
Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: JayMac on July 12, 2013, 00:19:11 Perhaps there needs to be a sliding scale of messages displayed on the screens to explain passenger loading:
Sardines Swing a cat Intimate Cosy Comfortable Relaxing Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: James on July 12, 2013, 01:25:40 Well jo thats a sign of the overpopulated south east that we now have.
What i have witnessed is something interesting or not if your not interested :) 70% of people disembark at maidenhead with around 10 % boarding and 20 % that is already on board until at least Reading where the whole population boards enroute to tilehurst, pangbourne and possibly goring. What i am amazed about is how the class 180 handles all that weight, without breaking down or doors failing. Good old british engineering :) Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: IndustryInsider on July 12, 2013, 11:26:07 What i am amazed about is how the class 180 handles all that weight, without breaking down or doors failing. Good old british engineering :) Bien s^r que oui! Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: Boppy on July 12, 2013, 14:41:39 I like bignosemac's idea! He has got the scale and descriptions nailed in my opinion! :-)
Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: johoare on July 12, 2013, 20:55:49 Perhaps there needs to be a sliding scale of messages displayed on the screens to explain passenger loading: Sardines Swing a cat Intimate Cosy Comfortable Relaxing I totally agree.. We definitely need at least one ahead of Sardines though.. if not two... Sardines is almost preferable ::) ::) Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: JayMac on July 12, 2013, 22:57:08 Okay.
What about Crowbar required at the head of the list? Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: mathmo on July 13, 2013, 01:05:59 I had the misfortune to get this train twice a week or so ago. (I don't usually commute to London.) It was unpleasantly busy, of course. But in my carriages I'd estimate fewer than half the passengers got off at Maidenhead. Is this because Off-Peak tickets can be used on it (as the announcements seemed to say)? Or are they just going to Twyford? Or was that rather unusual?
Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: James on July 13, 2013, 01:19:45 It could well be that people with off peak tickets travel as no one questions it, from what i have seen, travelling from Windsor to Maidenhead on a weekly basis. I presume the same can be said for other routes as well, who also allow off peak tickets. Seems crazy but at least its not quite as expensive as normal anytime tickets! Shame the mornings cant be off peak as well...
Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: James on July 13, 2013, 01:21:08 Industryinsider i love the french phrase, problem is i havent a clue what it means :)
Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: grahame on July 13, 2013, 05:47:28 Perhaps there needs to be a sliding scale of messages displayed on the screens to explain passenger loading: Sardines Swing a cat Intimate Cosy Comfortable Relaxing I totally agree.. We definitely need at least one ahead of Sardines though.. if not two... Sardines is almost preferable ::) ::) ... brimming, bulging. bursting, bursting, chock-a-block, completely full, cram full, crammed, jam-packed, overcrowded, overflowing, packed, packed like sardines, packed to capacity, stuffed ... 0 - 33% Relaxing 33% - 66 %Comfortable 66% - 100% Cosy 100% - 133% Intimate 133% - 166% Swing a cat 166% - 200% Sardines 200% up "Completely full" (to the extent that even officials who don't travel admit "it's full") [Percentages are seats taken] This scale replaces the historic scale of 50 years ago 0 - 8% Fresh Air 8% - 16% Quiet 16% - 24% Standard 24% - 32% Busy 32% - 40% Crowded 40% - 48% uncomfortable 49% + D**n it - what happened? How times have changed, and how much busier the railways are these days. I travelled to school on a quiet train (granted, it was contraflow) but how things have changed ... Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: gpn01 on July 15, 2013, 12:50:14 Perhaps there needs to be a sliding scale of messages displayed on the screens to explain passenger loading: Sardines Swing a cat Intimate Cosy Comfortable Relaxing I totally agree.. We definitely need at least one ahead of Sardines though.. if not two... Sardines is almost preferable ::) ::) ... brimming, bulging. bursting, bursting, chock-a-block, completely full, cram full, crammed, jam-packed, overcrowded, overflowing, packed, packed like sardines, packed to capacity, stuffed ... 0 - 33% Relaxing 33% - 66 %Comfortable 66% - 100% Cosy 100% - 133% Intimate 133% - 166% Swing a cat 166% - 200% Sardines 200% up "Completely full" (to the extent that even officials who don't travel admit "it's full") [Percentages are seats taken] This scale replaces the historic scale of 50 years ago 0 - 8% Fresh Air 8% - 16% Quiet 16% - 24% Standard 24% - 32% Busy 32% - 40% Crowded 40% - 48% uncomfortable 49% + D**n it - what happened? How times have changed, and how much busier the railways are these days. I travelled to school on a quiet train (granted, it was contraflow) but how things have changed ... "... brimming, bulging. bursting, bursting, chock-a-block, completely full, cram full, crammed, jam-packed, overcrowded, overflowing, packed, packed like sardines, packed to capacity, stuffed ..." ... This is also reported as "Normal Service" Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: Chris from Nailsea on July 20, 2013, 23:54:09 ... This is also reported as "Normal Service" :o ::) ;D Industryinsider i love the french phrase, problem is i havent a clue what it means :) Try http://translate.google.co.uk/#auto/en/Bien%20s%C3%BBr%20que%20oui! ;) Title: Re: Train reported to be full and standing Post by: Steve Bray on July 21, 2013, 15:45:23 I was at Reading station last Tuesday afternoon waiting to catc h the late-running 1622 to Worcester Shrub Hill, and I noticed that a train coming into Platform 10A to London (the 1426 Adelante from Gt Malvern) was reported to be 'full and standing'. When it came in, I looked and the 4 standard carriages did seem to be pretty full, with a few people standing at the end of the carriages. The 1st class carriage though only had 2 passengers so in reality, the train was only about 80% full. Perhaps the displays should say 'Standard Class Full & Standing'.
This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net |